• Refine by:
  • Clear
    Brand
    • Bare Minerals (1)
    • LORAC (2)
    • Laura Geller (2)
    • NYX Cosmetics (4)
    • Sigma Beauty (3)
    • Smashbox (3)
    • Tarte (6)
    • Winky Lux (3)
  • Clear
    Pricing
    • $10.00 & Under (4)
    • $15.00 & Under (10)
    • $25.00 & Under (24)
    • $50.00 & Under (24)
    • $75.00 & Under (24)
    • $100.00 & Under (24)

Shop Eye Makeup

Sort by:
NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Eye Pencil
$8.00
Why We Love It:

With this eye pencil, never worry about smearing and smudging. Pick one of many sleek shades to outline gorgeous eyes.

Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner
$23.00
Why We Love It:

There's never a dull day for this liner. Eyes always stay sharp with crisp dramatic lines and stunning definition.

Laura Geller Beauty INKcredible Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil
$22.00
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
$9.00
Why We Love It:

Define your look with an epic fluid liner that goes on effortlessly, whether fine and natural or bold and broad.

Winky Lux Feliner Eyeliner Pencil Bowtie
$13.00
Why We Love It:

Perfect cat-eye looks don't budge.

Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Two waterproof, liquid and pencil eyeliners in one amazing tarteist tool.

Tarte Tarteist Clay Paint Liner
Was: $24.00
Now: $12.00
Why We Love It:

Think outside the lines and unleash your inner tarteist as you define your eyes like a pro.

Sigma Beauty Gel Eye Liner - Wicked
$20.00
Why We Love It:

BBers love the intensity, drama and long-wear that this gel liner formula delivers.

Sigma Beauty Long Wear Eyeliner Pencil - Wicked
$15.00
Why We Love It:

Bbers love this pencil eyeliner because it stays put once applied. The rich pigment and creamy formula glide on for a flawless finish.

Laura Geller Line-n-Define Dual Dimension Eyeliner
$24.00
Why We Love It:

For those who love to experiment with dramatic eye looks and clamor for the perfect cat eye, this is the liner for you!

Sigma Beauty Liquid Pen Eyeliner - Wicked
$19.00
Why We Love It:

Our eyes POP with one swipe of this intense black liner. We love topping off any look with this liner because we can make the line thin and subtle or bold and dramatic.

Tarte quick stick waterproof shadow & liner
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Get a complete eye look in no time with Tarte quick stick" waterproof shadow & liner.

bareMinerals Mineralist Lasting Eyeliner
$19.00
Winky Lux Liquid Eyeliner
$13.00
Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner
$23.00
Why We Love It:

BB loves these super-rich eyeliner shades. They glide across eyes easily for a waterproof, smudge-free finish.

Smashbox Always On Liquid Eye Liner
$23.00
Why We Love It:

This ergonomic liquid eye liner pen gives you total control and ultimate precision.

Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner in Brown
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Create a wide range of eye looks with this longwear 2-in-1 liquid and gel pencil eyeliner.

Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner Travel Size
$15.00
Why We Love It:

Two waterproof, liquid and pencil eyeliners in one amazing tarteist tool.

Lorac PRO Liquid Eyeliner
$22.00
NYX Epic Wear Semi-Permanent Liquid Liner
$10.00
Why We Love It:

This liquid liner has your back! With this waterproof, smudge-proof and transfer-proof formula, it's the makeup must-have of festival season and beyond.

Winky Lux Feliner Liquid Eyeliner Black Cat
$13.00
Why We Love It:

Perfect cat-eye looks don't budge.

Lorac Front Of The Line PRO Eye Pencil
$20.00
NYX Epic Ink Liner - Brown
$8.00
Why We Love It:

Show off your winged liner looks for hours with this waterproof liquid eyeliner!

Tarte double take awake micro liquid liner & brightener
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Make your eyes pop with a 2-in-1 liner that brightens and defines.